Archive for the 'PMP' Category

Comparing PRINCE 2 and PMBOK 4th Edition



  

PMbook 4th Overview

The core of PMBOK is the description of 42 project management processes Each process belongs to a Knowledge area and process group.  

Process Groups are:  

  • Initiating: define a new project (or phase). Obtain the authorization to start.
  • Planning: establish the scope of the project, define the plan of approach for the project
  • Executing: execute project plan ( Do the Work )
  • Monitoring and Control: track project progress and check performances, identify required changes and initiate them
  • Closing: close the project (or phase).

The process groups represent a sequence of managing project start from Initiating to Closing.  

Knowledge areas are : 

  • Project Integration Management
  • Project Scope Management
  • Project Time Management
  • Project Cost Management
  • Project Quality Management
  • Project Human Resource Management
  • Project Communications Management
  • Project Risk Management
  • Project Procurement Management

Additional to that the PMBOK 4th edition has a large introduction section addressing a number of topics in relation to project management:  

  • Program and Portfolio management
  • Project Management Office
  • Operations management
  • Stakeholders
  • Project Lifecycle vs. Product Lifecycle
  • Organization influences on Project Management (matrix, functional, projectized).

Prince 2 Overview

Prince2 is the [ Standard Method For Project Management ]. It gives a very strong focus on the Business Case as the driver of the project. It is a process based approach to project management. The Activities in processes use Techniques & Components. The good thing that Prince 2 leaves to the project manager the right to choose the Techniques depending on the project context and organization.  

The main parts of Prince 2 are:

  • Processes :
    • They are made of activities with inputs and outputs. [ 8 Processes & 45 activities ]
  1. Starting up a project
  2. Initiating a project
  3. Planning
  4. Managing stage boundaries
  5. Controlling a stage
  6. Directing a project
  7. Managing product delivery
  8. Closing a project
  • Components
  1. Business case
  2. Organization
  3. Plans
  4. Controls
  5. Management of Risks
  6. Quality in a Project Environment
  7. Configuration Management
  8. Change Control
  9. Techniques
  10. Appendices
  • Techniques
  1. Product-based planning
  2. Change control
  3. Quality reviews

High Level comprising Between PMP & Prince2

 

PMBOK 4th  

Prince 2  

Started in United state
  

Started in united kingdom  

Over 240,000 PMI members worldwide  

Over 70,000 PRINCE2® Practitioners worldwide  

No software included  

No software included  

Not a methodology  

PRINCE2 is a methodology  

Website : www.PMI.org
  

Website : www.ogc.gov.uk/prince2
  

  

PMBOK 4th  

Prince 2  

Initiating   

  • Starting up a project  

  • Directing a Project  

  • Managing Stage Boundaries  

Planning   

  • Starting up a project  

  • Directing a Project  

  • Managing Stage Boundaries  

Executing   

  • Starting up a project  

  • Directing a Project  

  • Managing Stage Boundaries  

Monitoring and controlling   

  • Starting up a project  

  • Directing a Project  

  • Managing Stage Boundaries  

Closing   

  • Starting up a project  

  • Directing a Project  

  • Managing Stage Boundaries  

  

PMBOK 4th  

Prince 2  

PMBOK® Knowledge Area  

PRINCE2® Element  

Scope  

Business Case, Plans, Product Based
Planning, Change control
  

Time  

Plans, Planning, Product Based Planning,
Change control
  

Cost  

Plans, Planning, Change control  

Quality  

Quality/Quality Review, Configuration
Management
  

Risk  

Management of Risk  

Communications  

Controls, Controlling a Stage, Closing a
Project
  

Human Resources  

Only roles/responsibilities covered by
Organization
  

Procurement  

Not covered by PRINCE2®  


Do you Think PMBOK® and PRINCE2® are competitors ?!!
  

  • PRINCE2® is a practical Project management methodology.  

  • PMBOK® is a comprehensive source of information about all aspects of best practice Project Management.  

  • PMBOK and PRINCE2 are complimentary and can be used in conjunction for effective project management .  

  PMEA Team  

  Join us Today